Skip to main content

DUI Laws

Evidence and Testimony in a DUI Case: What We Subpoena and Why

A strong DUI defense is built on evidence — body cam footage, dash cam recordings, 911 calls, police reports, CHP records, and chemical test calibration logs. Learn what your attorney subpoenas, how that evidence is used in criminal court and at the DMV, and why gathering it immediately is critical.

By Michael P. Kade — Former LAPD Officer & Criminal Defense Attorney · Updated

Educational purposes only — not legal advice. This article provides general information about California DUI law and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Consult a licensed attorney for advice specific to your situation.

Key Takeaways

  • —Body cam and dash cam footage often contradict the officer's written report — and juries give video enormous weight
  • —911 call recordings reveal what the caller actually observed and can undermine the officer's probable cause
  • —Chemical test calibration and maintenance records are subpoenaed to challenge the accuracy of breath test results
  • —CHP incident reports, dispatch logs, and supplemental reports are subpoenaed in freeway and highway DUI cases
  • —Evidence gathered through subpoenas can be used both in criminal court and at the DMV APS hearing

A DUI case is not just about what the officer says happened. It is about what the evidence actually shows. Modern DUI investigations generate a substantial paper and digital trail — body-worn camera footage, patrol vehicle dash cam recordings, 911 call audio, computer-aided dispatch logs, police reports, supplemental reports, chemical test calibration records, blood draw documentation, and more. An experienced DUI defense attorney subpoenas all of it. Here is what we look for and why it matters.

Body-Worn Camera Footage

Most LAPD officers and California Highway Patrol officers wear body-worn cameras that activate automatically when they exit their vehicle or activate their emergency lights. The footage captures the traffic stop from the moment the officer approaches your window: your demeanor, your speech, your coordination, your performance on field sobriety tests, and the officer's instructions and conduct. Body cam footage is often the most powerful evidence in a DUI case — it either confirms the officer's written report or contradicts it. Officers sometimes describe a driver as 'slurring speech' or 'unable to maintain balance' in their report, only for the video to show a calm, articulate, steady individual. We subpoena body cam footage in every DUI case.

Patrol Vehicle Dash Camera Footage

Dash cameras mounted in patrol vehicles capture the driving behavior that led to the traffic stop — the weaving, the wide turn, the failure to signal that the officer claims justified the stop. If the dash cam shows normal driving, it directly undermines the officer's stated reason for the stop and can support a motion to suppress all evidence obtained as a result of the unlawful stop. Dash cam footage also captures the field sobriety tests from a different angle than the body cam, providing a more complete picture of the driver's actual performance.

911 Call Recordings

Many DUI arrests begin with a 911 call — a report of a reckless driver, a wrong-way driver, or a driver who appeared impaired. The 911 recording is subpoenaed because it reveals exactly what the caller observed and reported. If the caller described a vehicle that does not match your car, or described driving behavior that occurred miles away and hours before the stop, the recording can undermine the officer's probable cause. The recording also captures the caller's tone and certainty — a hesitant or uncertain caller is very different from a confident eyewitness. Computer-aided dispatch (CAD) logs are subpoenaed alongside the recording to document the timeline of the call and the officer's response.

Police Reports and Supplemental Reports

The arresting officer's initial police report is the foundation of the prosecution's case. But it is rarely the only report. Supplemental reports from backup officers, paramedics, and accident reconstruction specialists may also exist. We subpoena all of them. Inconsistencies between reports — different descriptions of the driver's behavior, different accounts of the field sobriety test instructions, different timelines — are powerful impeachment material. Officers are held to the accuracy of their written reports, and discrepancies between the report and the video, or between one officer's report and another's, can create reasonable doubt.

CHP Records in Freeway and Highway Cases

When a DUI arrest occurs on a California freeway or highway, the California Highway Patrol is typically the arresting agency. CHP maintains detailed incident reports, dispatch logs, officer activity logs, and supplemental documentation. We subpoena all CHP records related to the stop, including any communications between the officer and dispatch, any requests for backup, and any documentation of the field sobriety tests. CHP officers are also subject to subpoena for the DMV APS hearing, where their testimony can be cross-examined under oath — often for the first time before the criminal trial.

Chemical Test Calibration and Maintenance Records

Breath testing machines must be calibrated and maintained according to strict standards set out in Title 17 of the California Code of Regulations. We subpoena the calibration records, maintenance logs, and repair history for the specific machine used to test our client. A machine that was overdue for calibration, that had a history of malfunctions, or that was not maintained by a certified technician produces unreliable results. We also subpoena the operator's certification records to verify that the officer who administered the test was properly trained and certified. These records are subpoenaed for both the DMV hearing and the criminal case.

Blood Draw Documentation

In cases where a blood test was administered, we subpoena the blood draw documentation: the phlebotomist's credentials, the chain of custody records, the storage and refrigeration logs, the laboratory analysis report, and the analyst's qualifications. Blood samples can be contaminated, mislabeled, or improperly stored — any of which can affect the accuracy of the BAC result. California law also entitles the defendant to a portion of the blood sample for independent testing by a defense expert. We request the split sample immediately after arrest to preserve this right.

How This Evidence Is Used at the DMV and in Court

Evidence gathered through subpoenas serves a dual purpose. At the DMV APS hearing, it is used to challenge the three elements the DMV must prove: reasonable cause for the stop, lawfulness of the arrest, and accuracy of the chemical test. At the criminal trial, it is used to cross-examine the officer, impeach inconsistent testimony, support motions to suppress, and argue reasonable doubt to the jury. The DMV hearing often occurs before the criminal trial, which means the officer's testimony under cross-examination at the DMV hearing is preserved — and can be used to impeach them if their story changes at trial.

Penalties at a Glance

Offense / SituationPotential Penalty
Evidence suppressed — unlawful stopCase potentially dismissed; DMV suspension set aside
Breath machine not properly calibratedBAC result challenged; reduced charge or dismissal possible
Blood chain of custody brokenBAC result excluded; case significantly weakened

Penalties shown are general ranges. Actual sentences depend on the specific facts of your case.

How Attorney Kade Defends These Cases

  • —Subpoena body cam and dash cam footage immediately — footage may be overwritten if not preserved
  • —Subpoena 911 call recordings and CAD logs to challenge the basis for the traffic stop
  • —Obtain all police reports and supplemental reports and compare them for inconsistencies
  • —Subpoena breath machine calibration and maintenance records and challenge Title 17 compliance
  • —Request the split blood sample for independent analysis by a defense toxicologist
  • —Subpoena the phlebotomist's credentials and the blood chain of custody documentation
  • —Use DMV hearing cross-examination to lock in the officer's testimony before the criminal trial

Frequently Asked Questions